The Richmond Review

book review   


      home : book reviews : The Age of Wire and String by Ben Marcus

Book cover

The Bear & his Daughter
Robert Stone

The Bear & his Daughter
Robert Stone
London 1998

Merchandise Links

UK Edition:

US Edition:

The Bear & his Daughter is a collection of seven short stories written over the past thirty years and presented here as Robert Stone’s first collection. Stone is the author of five ‘acclaimed’ novels which, according to his blurb, focus on standard American preoccupations such as ‘the jungles of Vietnam’ and ‘the sinister glamour of Hollywood’. The stories featured here reflect other favourite Stateside obsessions such as alcoholism, the politics of abortion and that good old staple of postmodern culture, psychotherapy.

The first story in the collection, ‘Miserere’, is a grim account of a woman who has become involved in the bizarre and extremist world of anti-abortion campaign work. It is probably the best story in the book, not for its execution but for its premise. Stone introduces the reader to a group of broken, bereaved women who find a strange solace and redemption through recovering foetal corpses from the trash cans of abortion clinics and taking them to Catholic priests for blessing and Christian burial. It is wonderfully, grotesquely gothic in parts and there is genuine poignancy in this story as Stone takes us to the very edges of religious fanaticism and personal tragedy, but the narrative is overburdened by detail. Stone wants us to understand his protagonist and her motivations so he gives us not only her life history but a lot of unwelcome and unnecessary detail about her daily routine. This does not serve to illuminate but merely to diffuse the potential emotional intensity of the story. It is overlong and displays a total disregard for the economy that is essential to a good short story. Stone tries to cram a novel’s worth of background behind the action of most of the stories in this book and in doing so displays a real lack of understanding of his genre.

The story ‘Helping’ is apparently much anthologised, probably because it is the one about psychotherapy. Our starring psychotherapist, Chas Elliot is (surprise, surprise) actually a bit mad himself, an alcoholic, in an unhappy marriage, etc. etc. He has been on the wagon for quite some time and, in this story, Stone treats us to the sight of his inevitable fall from it. Elliot is very unhappy, as are all of Stone’s characters. His wife is unhappy, his colleagues and his patients are unhappy. His neighbours are happy but Elliot, and seemingly Stone too, despises them. He seems incapable of writing happy people without making them seem like ghastly, hollow parodies of happiness, dark versions of the Flanders family from The Simpsons. There is no redemption for Stone’s characters, no real sense of hope in any of these stories. The darkness is complete and this smacks of a rather adolescent self-indulgence and unattractive misanthropy on the part of the writer.

‘Helping’ is full of dialogue, which is probably the weakest aspect of Stone’s writing. It is clipped, over stylised, and like no conversation you ever heard in your life:

‘God’ she said. ‘What have I done. I’m so drunk.

‘Most of the time,’ Elliot said, sighting down the barrel, ‘I’m helpless in the face of human misery. Tonight I’m ready to reach out.’

‘I’m finished,’ Grace said. ‘I’m through, Chas. I mean it.’

This preposterous, sub B-movie kind of dialogue is a hallmark of Stone’s approach to storytelling, the effect of which is to render even the most emotionally complex relationships in the book shallow and bordering on absurdity.

Another prevailing theme in The Bear & his Daughter is recreational drug use/abuse, and it is one that very much reflects the writer’s generation. The story ‘Porque no Trene, Porque la Falta’ is a surrealistic, drug-addled tale of sixties drop-out culture in Mexico. It reads like a Freak Brothers cartoon strip, unfortunately without the humour. Stone is a man who takes both his writing and his subject matter very seriously and if there is humour of any kind to be found in these stories it is so black as to be almost imperceptible. His prose is macho and often pompous. Take this passage, for example, from ‘Under the Pitons’:

Blessington was trying to forget the anxieties of the deal, the stink of menace, the sick ache behind the eyes. It was dreadful to have to smoke with the St. Vincentian dealers, stone killers who liked to operate from behind a thin film of fear. But the Frenchman was tough.

This kind of writing is reminiscent of the cheap spin-off novels that are written based on Hollywood blockbuster movies, the kind of prose that you can imagine being read aloud by the gravelly and portentious voice that accompanies most American movie trailers. Stone is a writer who has undergone a complete irony bypass. Either that or he is a brilliant and masterfully opaque self-parodist. I suspect the first, and I also suspect that I may have read an entirely different collection of stories to the American reviewer cited on the back of the book that refer to its ‘hugeness of soul’. ‘Whatever keeps me going’ says one of the characters in ‘Helping’, ‘it isn’t optimism’. The same may be said of Robert Stone. I wouldn’t like to speculate on what does keep him going, only to say that I hope it runs out soon.

Reviewed by Polly Rance


Search The Richmond Review

Enter email address and Subscribe for updates

Product finder

Browse our network:

Visit The Big Bookshop


The Richmond Review

Copyright © 1995/2003 The Richmond Review